Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System
The article presents the results of a qualitative research that aimed to describe and assess the quality of the judgments in the accusatory criminal system in Mexico City, Mexico. A non-statistical sample of judgments dictated during 2019 by judges of the local Superior Court of Justice was selected...
Saved in:
| Main Author: | |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
2022
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/oaiart?codigo=8845215 |
| Source: | Revista Estudios Socio-Jurídicos, ISSN 2145-4531, Vol. 24, Nº. 2, 2022 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Revista Estudios socio-jurídicos) |
| Tags: |
Add Tag
No Tags: Be the first to tag this record
|
| id |
dialnet-ar-18-ART0001585305
|
|---|---|
| record_format |
dialnet
|
| spelling |
dialnet-ar-18-ART00015853052023-03-15Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System Fonseca Luján, Roberto Carlosjudgmentsqualityjudicial reasoningjustificationsentenciascalidadrazonamiento judicialmotivaciónThe article presents the results of a qualitative research that aimed to describe and assess the quality of the judgments in the accusatory criminal system in Mexico City, Mexico. A non-statistical sample of judgments dictated during 2019 by judges of the local Superior Court of Justice was selected and evaluated with an instrument which captures information about the stylistic and argumentative quality of the judgment. It is concluded that, regardless of the legal correctness, the judgments in the Mexican accusatory system show a non-optimal degree of quality, with problems associated to the lack of clarity and the weakness of reasoning in the justification.El artículo presenta los resultados de una investigación cualitativa que tuvo por objeto describir y valorar la calidad de las sentencias dictadas en el sistema penal acusatorio en la Ciudad de México, México. Se seleccionó una muestra no estadística de sentencias dictadas por jueces del Tribunal Superior de Justicia local durante 2019, las cuales se valoraron con base en un instrumento que captura información sobre la calidad estilística y la calidad argumentativa de la sentencia. Se concluye que, independientemente de la corrección jurídica, las sentencias en el sistema acusatorio mexicano muestran un grado de calidad no óptimo, con problemas asociados a la falta de claridad y la debilidad de los razonamientos en la motivación.2022text (article)application/pdfhttps://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/oaiart?codigo=8845215(Revista) ISSN 0124-0579(Revista) ISSN 2145-4531Revista Estudios Socio-Jurídicos, ISSN 2145-4531, Vol. 24, Nº. 2, 2022 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Revista Estudios socio-jurídicos)engLICENCIA DE USO: Los documentos a texto completo incluidos en Dialnet son de acceso libre y propiedad de sus autores y/o editores. Por tanto, cualquier acto de reproducción, distribución, comunicación pública y/o transformación total o parcial requiere el consentimiento expreso y escrito de aquéllos. Cualquier enlace al texto completo de estos documentos deberá hacerse a través de la URL oficial de éstos en Dialnet. Más información: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/info/derechosOAI | INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS STATEMENT: Full text documents hosted by Dialnet are protected by copyright and/or related rights. This digital object is accessible without charge, but its use is subject to the licensing conditions set by its authors or editors. Unless expressly stated otherwise in the licensing conditions, you are free to linking, browsing, printing and making a copy for your own personal purposes. All other acts of reproduction and communication to the public are subject to the licensing conditions expressed by editors and authors and require consent from them. Any link to this document should be made using its official URL in Dialnet. More info: https://dialnet.unirioja.es/info/derechosOAI
|
| institution |
Dialnet
|
| collection |
Dialnet AR
|
| source |
Revista Estudios Socio-Jurídicos, ISSN 2145-4531, Vol. 24, Nº. 2, 2022 (Ejemplar dedicado a: Revista Estudios socio-jurídicos)
|
| language |
English
|
| topic |
judgments
quality judicial reasoning justification sentencias calidad razonamiento judicial motivación |
| spellingShingle |
judgments
quality judicial reasoning justification sentencias calidad razonamiento judicial motivación Fonseca Luján, Roberto Carlos Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System |
| description |
The article presents the results of a qualitative research that aimed to describe and assess the quality of the judgments in the accusatory criminal system in Mexico City, Mexico. A non-statistical sample of judgments dictated during 2019 by judges of the local Superior Court of Justice was selected and evaluated with an instrument which captures information about the stylistic and argumentative quality of the judgment. It is concluded that, regardless of the legal correctness, the judgments in the Mexican accusatory system show a non-optimal degree of quality, with problems associated to the lack of clarity and the weakness of reasoning in the justification.
|
| format |
Article
|
| author |
Fonseca Luján, Roberto Carlos
|
| author_facet |
Fonseca Luján, Roberto Carlos
|
| author_sort |
Fonseca Luján, Roberto Carlos
|
| title |
Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System
|
| title_short |
Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System
|
| title_full |
Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System
|
| title_fullStr |
Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System
|
| title_full_unstemmed |
Quality of Judgments in the Mexico City Accusatory Criminal System
|
| title_sort |
quality of judgments in the mexico city accusatory criminal system
|
| publishDate |
2022
|
| url |
https://dialnet.unirioja.es/servlet/oaiart?codigo=8845215
|
| _version_ |
1760582299316912128
|